Used Tesla Model Y, VW ID.4 or Volvo XC40? Elbilsmagasinet's Comparison
8 March 2026 · PrivatLeasa.se · Läs på svenska
Elbilsmagasinet has done a really thorough comparison of three of the most popular used EVs on the market: Tesla Model Y, Volkswagen ID.4 and Volvo XC40 Recharge. All three from 2021, all in the price range 290,000–350,000 SEK. This is a summary of Elbilsmagasinet's excellent video — but we strongly recommend watching the full test for all the details.
Three Used EVs — What Do They Cost?
Elbilsmagasinet has chosen three specimens from 2021 in comparable price range:
| Car | Used Price | Model Year |
|---|---|---|
| Tesla Model Y | ~290,000–320,000 SEK | 2021 |
| Volkswagen ID.4 | ~290,000–330,000 SEK | 2021 |
| Volvo XC40 Recharge | ~310,000–350,000 SEK | 2021 |
Prices vary depending on mileage, equipment and condition. Elbilsmagasinet does a thorough review of space, economy and the most common faults on each model.
Space — Who Wins?
One of the most practical parts of Elbilsmagasinet's comparison concerns space. Tesla Model Y has the largest cargo volume, while Volvo XC40 Recharge offers a more traditional sedan layout that many experience as more ergonomic. Volkswagen ID.4 falls in between — spacious but without Tesla's frunk.
Common Faults to Watch For
This is gold for anyone considering used EV purchase. Elbilsmagasinet goes through the most common issues for each model:
- Tesla Model Y (2021): Quality variations in fit and finish, software issues, wind noise at higher speeds
- Volkswagen ID.4 (2021): Early software versions could be buggy, touchscreen response, 12V battery faults
- Volvo XC40 Recharge (2021): Software updates required, some infotainment system problems, generally high quality feel
In their video, Elbilsmagasinet goes into detail about each model's weaknesses — invaluable knowledge if you're shopping used.
Used vs Private Leasing a New Car
Buying a used EV for 290,000–350,000 SEK means a cash payment and risk of unexpected repairs. The alternative? Private leasing a brand new car with warranty, service and fixed monthly cost:
| Car (new) | Private Leasing | Service | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| Tesla Model Y | 4,995 SEK/month | not incl. | Tesla |
| Volvo EX40 (successor to XC40) | 5,195 SEK/month | incl. | Volvo |
| Volkswagen ID.4 | 5,995 SEK/month | incl. | Volkswagen |
A used Tesla Model Y 2021 for 300,000 SEK with a car loan over 5 years gives roughly 5,000–5,500 SEK/month — comparable to leasing a new one. The difference? With private leasing you avoid the risks with used batteries, unexpected repairs and depreciation. You always drive a new car with full warranty.
Do the Math: Used vs Leasing
- Used Tesla Model Y (2021): ~300,000 SEK, ~5,200 SEK/month with loan (5 years, 4% interest) + insurance ~700 SEK + service ~300 SEK = ~6,200 SEK/month total
- New Tesla Model Y (private leasing): 4,995 SEK/month + insurance ~800 SEK = ~5,795 SEK/month total — with full warranty and new car
Private leasing a new Tesla Model Y can actually be cheaper than buying a used one — and you avoid the risk with degraded batteries and unknown history.
See Elbilsmagasinet's Full Comparison
Elbilsmagasinet delivers as always a thorough and fair comparison. The video is over 30 minutes of practical tests, economic calculations and honest opinions. Watch the full video if you're considering buying a used EV — it could save you thousands.
Considering a new car instead? Compare all EV offers in private leasing on privatleasa.se and see what fits your budget.